Documentation survey

SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment

This document provides a detailed overview of the VolumeAttachment custom resource for SUSE Storage, its integration with Kubernetes' native VolumeAttachment, operational flow, and common troubleshooting scenarios.

Kubernetes and SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment

To understand how volume attachments work in SUSE Storage, it is important to distinguish between VolumeAttachment of Kubernetes and custom VolumeAttachment of SUSE Storage:

  • Kubernetes VolumeAttachment: This is a native Kubernetes API resource that is part of the Container Storage Interface (CSI) specification. Its primary role is to signal a CSI driver that a volume should be attached to a specific node.

  • SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment: This is a Custom Resource (CR) defined by SUSE Storage, with the full name volumeattachment.longhorn.io. This internal SUSE Storage resource is used by the Longhorn Manager to track and manage all attachment requests for a volume.

SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment

VolumeAttachment CR

To retrieve a SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment CR, use the following command:

kubectl -n longhorn-system get volumeattachment.longhorn.io <volume-name> -o yaml

Example Output:

apiVersion: v1
...
  spec:
    attachmentTickets:
      csi-f0471a334f0b249f964cd1dec461a5eb94c8d268cbbc904c1a8e9a37e2045208:
        generation: 0
        id: csi-f0471a334f0b249f964cd1dec461a5eb94c8d268cbbc904c1a8e9a37e2045208
        nodeID: rancher60-master
        parameters:
          disableFrontend: "false"
          lastAttachedBy: ""
        type: csi-attacher
    volume: pvc-b26e9514-aafd-46e0-b70c-4e3f187c7977
  status:
    attachmentTicketStatuses:
      csi-f0471a334f0b249f964cd1dec461a5eb94c8d268cbbc904c1a8e9a37e2045208:
        conditions:
        - lastProbeTime: ""
          lastTransitionTime: "2025-07-05T09:17:27Z"
          message: ""
          reason: ""
          status: "True"
          type: Satisfied
        generation: 0
        id: csi-f0471a334f0b249f964cd1dec461a5eb94c8d268cbbc904c1a8e9a37e2045208
        satisfied: true
...

  • spec.attachmentTickets: A map containing all active attachment requests, also known as tickets. Each ticket includes:

    • id: A unique identifier for the attachment ticket.

    • nodeID: The ID of the node where the volume should be attached.

    • parameters: Optional parameters for the attachment, such as disableFrontend and lastAttachedBy.

    • type: The attacher type, indicating the source of the attachment request.

  • status.attachmentTicketStatuses: A map containing the current status of each active attachment ticket or request. Each entry includes:

    • conditions: The current condition(s) of the ticket, including whether the request is satisfied.

    • satisfied: A boolean value indicating whether the attachment request has been fulfilled.

    • generation: The generation number of the ticket, used to track updates.

Understanding Attachment Tickets

The SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment custom resource (CR) manages attachment requests from various internal SUSE Storage system controllers. Each request is represented as an attachment ticket within the CR.

All active tickets are stored in the spec.attachmentTickets map. The type field in each ticket (referred to as the AttacherType) identifies the source of the request. Common AttacherType values include:

  • csi-attacher: The most common type, handling standard attachment requests from the Kubernetes CSI plugin, typically when mounting a volume to a pod.

  • longhorn-api: Represents a manual attachment request initiated by a user through the SUSE Storage UI or API.

  • snapshot-controller: Used when attaching a volume to create or restore a snapshot.

  • backup-controller: Used when attaching a volume to perform a backup.

  • volume-restore-controller: Used when attaching a volume during a restore operation.

  • volume-clone-controller: Used when attaching a volume for cloning from an existing volume.

  • share-manager-controller: Manages backend volume attachments for ReadWriteMany (RWX) volumes by attaching them to the share-manager pod.

  • volume-expansion-controller: Handles attachments needed for online volume expansion.

  • volume-rebuilding-controller: Used when attaching a volume to rebuild a degraded or missing replica.

  • salvage-controller: Used during the salvage process when SUSE Storage attempts to recover and reattach a problematic volume.

  • volume-eviction-controller: Handles attachments involved in evicting a replica from a node.

  • bim-ds-controller: Used by the Backing Image Data Source controller when creating a volume from a backing image.

The CSI Attachment and Detachment Workflow

To understand how SUSE Storage integrates with Kubernetes, it is important to examine how the native Kubernetes VolumeAttachment resource and the SUSE Storage custom VolumeAttachment CR interact through the CSI interface.

Core Components in the Workflow

In addition to the Kubernetes and SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment objects, several key components work together to manage volume attachment and detachment:

  • external-attacher: A CSI sidecar container that monitors Kubernetes VolumeAttachment objects and triggers ControllerPublishVolume or ControllerUnpublishVolume gRPC calls to the Longhorn CSI driver.

  • longhorn-csi-plugin: The Longhorn CSI driver that implements the required CSI gRPC services.

  • longhorn-manager: The central controller in SUSE Storage that manages the full lifecycle of Longhorn volumes. It includes various sub-controllers, including the volume attachment logic.

  • longhorn-volume-attachment-controller: A sub-controller within longhorn-manager that monitors the SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment CR and performs attach or detach operations based on its spec.

The CSI Volume Attachment Flow

When a pod that uses a Longhorn PersistentVolumeClaim (PVC) is scheduled onto a node, the CSI volume attachment workflow begins.

  1. Kubelet Request: The kubelet on the target node detects that a Longhorn volume needs to be mounted and notifies the Kubernetes attach-detach-controller.

  2. Kubernetes VolumeAttachment Creation: The attach-detach-controller creates a Kubernetes VolumeAttachment object, specifying the Longhorn CSI driver (driver.longhorn.io), the target node name, and the persistent volume name.

  3. external-attacher Triggers CSI Call: The external-attacher sidecar container observes the new Kubernetes VolumeAttachment object and issues a ControllerPublishVolume gRPC call to the longhorn-csi-plugin.

  4. Longhorn VolumeAttachment CR Creation: Rather than attaching the volume directly, the longhorn-csi-plugin creates a Longhorn VolumeAttachment custom resource (CR). It adds an attachment ticket to the spec of CR to represent the attachment request.

  5. Longhorn Controller Reconciliation: The longhorn-volume-attachment-controller, a sub-controller within longhorn-manager, detects the new ticket and begins reconciliation. It verifies that the volume is available and updates the spec.nodeID field of the corresponding Volume CR with the target node name.

  6. longhorn-manager Executes Attachment: After detecting that spec.nodeID is set, longhorn-manager starts the Longhorn Engine on the specified node to complete the attachment.

  7. Volume Attachment Completion:

    • longhorn-manager updates the status of the Volume CR to reflect that the volume is attached.

    • The longhorn-volume-attachment-controller updates the status of the Longhorn VolumeAttachment CR to indicate success.

    • The longhorn-csi-plugin receives the successful status and responds to the external-attacher.

    • Finally, the external-attacher marks the status.attached field of the Kubernetes VolumeAttachment object as true.

  8. Kubelet Mounts the Volume: Once the volume is marked as attached, the kubelet proceeds with the NodeStageVolume and NodePublishVolume CSI calls to mount the volume into the pod’s container.

The CSI Volume Detachment Flow

When a pod using a Longhorn volume is deleted or rescheduled, the CSI detachment workflow begins.

  1. Kubelet Request: The kubelet signals to the Kubernetes attach-detach-controller that the volume is no longer needed on the node.

  2. Kubernetes VolumeAttachment Deletion: The attach-detach-controller deletes the corresponding Kubernetes VolumeAttachment object.

  3. external-attacher Triggers CSI Call: The external-attacher observes the deletion and initiates a ControllerUnpublishVolume gRPC call to the longhorn-csi-plugin.

  4. Attachment Ticket Removal: The longhorn-csi-plugin processes the request by updating the SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment CR to remove the relevant attachment ticket.

  5. Longhorn Controller Reconciliation: The longhorn-volume-attachment-controller detects that the ticket has been removed. If no other tickets exist for the volume, it clears the spec.nodeID field in the Longhorn Volume CR.

  6. longhorn-manager Executes Detachment: With the spec.nodeID cleared, longhorn-manager initiates the detachment process by stopping the Longhorn Engine on the node.

  7. Volume Detachment Completion:

    • longhorn-manager updates the status of the Volume CR to indicate that the volume is detached.

    • The longhorn-csi-plugin receives confirmation and responds with success to the external-attacher.

    • The external-attacher removes the finalizer from the Kubernetes VolumeAttachment object, allowing the API server to fully delete it.

Summary of the Workflow

SUSE Storage extends the native volume attachment mechanism of Kubernetes by introducing a custom VolumeAttachment CR. This design provides several advantages:

  • Decoupling and Abstraction: The custom resource encapsulates complex attach or detach logic within SUSE Storage, reducing the responsibilities of the longhorn-csi-plugin.

  • Fine-Grained Control: The attachment ticket system enables SUSE Storage to handle requests from multiple sources (for example, pods, snapshots, backups) while ensuring only one valid attachment per volume at any time.

  • Observability and Troubleshooting: The CR provides clear visibility into the volume’s attachment state and history, simplifying monitoring and troubleshooting.

In summary, the Kubernetes VolumeAttachment object initiates the attachment or detachment process, while SUSE Storage’s custom VolumeAttachment CR orchestrates and manages the actual operations internally.

Troubleshooting Volume Attachment Issues

This section outlines common issues related to volume attachment and provides recommended resolution steps. Before making any changes, carefully inspect system logs and relevant custom resources to avoid disrupting active workloads.

Volume is Stuck in Attaching or Detaching State

When a volume remains in the Attaching or Detaching state for an extended period, the cause is often related to stale or conflicting attachment tickets in the SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment CR.

Possible Causes

  • Stale or Orphaned Tickets: A ticket from a previous workload (for example, a deleted pod or completed backup job) was not properly removed and still exists under spec.attachmentTickets.

  • Conflicting Tickets: An existing ticket (for example, from the CSI attacher) blocks a new request (for example, a manual detach or move to a different node).

Resolution Steps

  1. Inspect the SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment CR: Use the following command to view the attachment tickets:

    kubectl -n longhorn-system get volumeattachment.longhorn.io <volume-name> -o yaml

  2. Analyze Ticket Sources: Look under spec.attachmentTickets and check the type field for each ticket to identify its source (for example, csi-attacher, backup-controller, etc.).

  3. Remove Invalid Tickets with Caution: If you confirm a ticket is no longer needed (for example, its corresponding pod has been deleted), you may remove it by editing the CR.

    Deleting an active ticket can cause serious disruptions. If you remove a ticket still required by a running workload, SUSE Storage interprets this as a detach request:

    • The volume engine will stop on the node, causing the pod to lose storage access and encounter input-output errors, likely crashing the pod.

    • Kubernetes CSI will eventually detect the issue and re-attach the volume, recreating the ticket, but this causes downtime and may require manual pod restart.

    Always verify that the workload related to the ticket is inactive before removing it.

  4. Verify the State: After removing invalid tickets, SUSE Storage should be able to complete the attach or detach operation successfully.

Case Study

Case 1: Failure to Attach Volume Due to Unexpected longhorn-ui Attachment Ticket

  • Issue: #8339

  • Symptom:

    • Workloads using the affected volume remain stuck in Pending state.

    • The SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment CR contains an unexpected ticket from longhorn-ui.

  • Workaround:

    • Inspect the VolumeAttachment CR:

      kubectl -n longhorn-system get volumeattachment.longhorn.io <volume-name> -o yaml

    • If you find a longhorn-ui attachment ticket, remove the entire ticket block from the CR.

Case 2: Volume Fails to Attach to New Node Due to Backup Job Stuck in Pending State

  • Issue: #10090

  • Symptom:

    • When a workload is rescheduled to a different node, the volume fails to follow.

    • Backup jobs referencing non-existent snapshots remain stuck in Pending state, with status.message containing failed to get the snapshot …​ not found.

    • These stuck backup jobs hold onto the volume, blocking detach or reattach.

  • Workaround:

    1. Check the SUSE Storage VolumeAttachment CR for any tickets locking the volume:

      kubectl -n longhorn-system get volumeattachment.longhorn.io <volume-name> -o yaml

    2. If you see a ticket from the backup controller, a backup job is locking the volume.

    3. Do not delete the backup-* attachment ticket directly, as SUSE Storage will recreate it.

    4. Instead, resolve the stuck backup job by removing any Backup CRs with:

      • status.state = pending

      • status.message containing Failed to get the Snapshot…​

        This releases the volume and allows it to be reattached.