Applies to SUSE Linux Enterprise High Availability 15 SP5

17 Load balancing #

Load Balancing makes a cluster of servers appear as one large, fast server to outside clients. This apparent single server is called a virtual server. It consists of one or more load balancers dispatching incoming requests and several real servers running the actual services. With a load balancing setup of SUSE Linux Enterprise High Availability, you can build highly scalable and highly available network services, such as Web, cache, mail, FTP, media and VoIP services.

17.1 Conceptual overview #

SUSE Linux Enterprise High Availability supports two technologies for load balancing: Linux Virtual Server (LVS) and HAProxy. The key difference is Linux Virtual Server operates at OSI layer 4 (Transport), configuring the network layer of kernel, while HAProxy operates at layer 7 (Application), running in user space. Thus Linux Virtual Server needs fewer resources and can handle higher loads, while HAProxy can inspect the traffic, do SSL termination and make dispatching decisions based on the content of the traffic.

On the other hand, Linux Virtual Server includes two different software: IPVS (IP Virtual Server) and KTCPVS (Kernel TCP Virtual Server). IPVS provides layer 4 load balancing whereas KTCPVS provides layer 7 load balancing.

This section gives you a conceptual overview of load balancing in combination with high availability, then briefly introduces you to Linux Virtual Server and HAProxy. Finally, it points you to further reading.

The real servers and the load balancers may be interconnected by either high-speed LAN or by geographically dispersed WAN. The load balancers dispatch requests to the different servers. They make parallel services of the cluster appear as one virtual service on a single IP address (the virtual IP address or VIP). Request dispatching can use IP load balancing technologies or application-level load balancing technologies. Scalability of the system is achieved by transparently adding or removing nodes in the cluster.

High availability is provided by detecting node or service failures and reconfiguring the whole virtual server system appropriately, as usual.

There are several load balancing strategies. Here are some Layer 4 strategies, suitable for Linux Virtual Server:

Round robin. The simplest strategy is to direct each connection to a different address, taking turns. For example, a DNS server can have several entries for a given host name. With DNS round robin, the DNS server will return all of them in a rotating order. Thus different clients will see different addresses.
Selecting the “best” server. Although this has several drawbacks, balancing could be implemented with a “first server who responds” or “least loaded server” approach.
Balancing the number of connections per server. A load balancer between users and servers can divide the number of users across multiple servers.
Geographical location. It is possible to direct clients to a server nearby.

Here are some Layer 7 strategies, suitable for HAProxy:

URI. Inspect the HTTP content and dispatch to a server most suitable for this specific URI.
URL parameter, RDP cookie. Inspect the HTTP content for a session parameter, possibly in post parameters, or the RDP (remote desktop protocol) session cookie, and dispatch to the server serving this session.

Although there is some overlap, HAProxy can be used in scenarios where LVS/ipvsadm is not adequate and vice versa:

SSL termination. The front-end load balancers can handle the SSL layer. Thus the cloud nodes do not need to have access to the SSL keys, or could take advantage of SSL accelerators in the load balancers.
Application level. HAProxy operates at the application level, allowing the load balancing decisions to be influenced by the content stream. This allows for persistence based on cookies and other such filters.

On the other hand, LVS/ipvsadm cannot be fully replaced by HAProxy:

LVS supports “direct routing”, where the load balancer is only in the inbound stream, whereas the outbound traffic is routed to the clients directly. This allows for potentially much higher throughput in asymmetric environments.
LVS supports stateful connection table replication (via conntrackd). This allows for load balancer failover that is transparent to the client and server.

17.2 Configuring load balancing with Linux Virtual Server #

The following sections give an overview of the main LVS components and concepts. Then we explain how to set up Linux Virtual Server on SUSE Linux Enterprise High Availability.

17.2.1 Director #

The main component of LVS is the ip_vs (or IPVS) Kernel code. It is part of the default Kernel and implements transport-layer load balancing inside the Linux Kernel (layer-4 switching). The node that runs a Linux Kernel including the IPVS code is called director. The IPVS code running on the director is the essential feature of LVS.

When clients connect to the director, the incoming requests are load-balanced across all cluster nodes. The director forwards packets to the real servers, using a modified set of routing rules that make the LVS work. For example, connections do not originate or terminate on the director, it does not send acknowledgments. The director acts as a specialized router that forwards packets from end users to real servers (the hosts that run the applications that process the requests).

17.2.2 User space controller and daemons #

The ldirectord daemon is a user space daemon for managing Linux Virtual Server and monitoring the real servers in an LVS cluster of load balanced virtual servers. A configuration file (see below) specifies the virtual services and their associated real servers and tells ldirectord how to configure the server as an LVS redirector. When the daemon is initialized, it creates the virtual services for the cluster.

By periodically requesting a known URL and checking the responses, the ldirectord daemon monitors the health of the real servers. If a real server fails, it is removed from the list of available servers at the load balancer. When the service monitor detects that the dead server has recovered and is working again, it adds the server back to the list of available servers. In case that all real servers should be down, a fall-back server can be specified to which to redirect a Web service. Typically the fall-back server is localhost, presenting an emergency page about the Web service being temporarily unavailable.

The ldirectord uses the ipvsadm tool (package ipvsadm) to manipulate the virtual server table in the Linux Kernel.

17.2.3 Packet forwarding #

There are three different methods of how the director can send packets from the client to the real servers:

Network address translation (NAT): Incoming requests arrive at the virtual IP. They are forwarded to the real servers by changing the destination IP address and port to that of the chosen real server. The real server sends the response to the load balancer which in turn changes the destination IP address and forwards the response back to the client. Thus, the end user receives the replies from the expected source. As all traffic goes through the load balancer, it usually becomes a bottleneck for the cluster.
IP tunneling (IP-IP encapsulation): IP tunneling enables packets addressed to an IP address to be redirected to another address, possibly on a different network. The LVS sends requests to real servers through an IP tunnel (redirecting to a different IP address) and the real servers reply directly to the client using their own routing tables. Cluster members can be in different subnets.
Direct routing: Packets from end users are forwarded directly to the real server. The IP packet is not modified, so the real servers must be configured to accept traffic for the virtual server's IP address. The response from the real server is sent directly to the client. The real servers and load balancers need to be in the same physical network segment.

17.2.4 Scheduling algorithms #

Deciding which real server to use for a new connection requested by a client is implemented using different algorithms. They are available as modules and can be adapted to specific needs. For an overview of available modules, refer to the ipvsadm(8) man page. Upon receiving a connect request from a client, the director assigns a real server to the client based on a schedule. The scheduler is the part of the IPVS Kernel code which decides which real server gets the next new connection.

More detailed description about Linux Virtual Server scheduling algorithms can be found at http://kb.linuxvirtualserver.org/wiki/IPVS. Furthermore, search for --scheduler in the ipvsadm man page.

Related load balancing strategies for HAProxy can be found at https://www.haproxy.org/download/1.6/doc/configuration.txt.

17.2.5 Setting up IP load balancing with YaST #

You can configure Kernel-based IP load balancing with the YaST IP Load Balancing module. It is a front-end for ldirectord.

To access the IP Load Balancing dialog, start YaST as root and select High Availability › IP Load Balancing. Alternatively, start the YaST cluster module as root on a command line with yast2 iplb.

The default installation does not include the configuration file /etc/ha.d/ldirectord.cf. This file is created by the YaST module. The tabs available in the YaST module correspond to the structure of the /etc/ha.d/ldirectord.cf configuration file, defining global options and defining the options for the virtual services.

For an example configuration and the resulting processes between load balancers and real servers, refer to Example 17.1, “Simple ldirectord configuration”.

Note: Global parameters and virtual server parameters

If a certain parameter is specified in both the virtual server section and in the global section, the value defined in the virtual server section overrides the value defined in the global section.

Procedure 17.1: Configuring global parameters #

The following procedure describes how to configure the most important global parameters. For more details about the individual parameters (and the parameters not covered here), click Help or refer to the ldirectord man page.

With Check Interval, define the interval in which ldirectord connects to each of the real servers to check if they are still online.
With Check Timeout, set the time in which the real server should have responded after the last check.
With Failure Count you can define how many times ldirectord attempts to request the real servers until the check is considered failed.
With Negotiate Timeout define a timeout in seconds for negotiate checks.
In Fallback, enter the host name or IP address of the Web server onto which to redirect a Web service in case all real servers are down.
If you want the system to send alerts in case the connection status to any real server changes, enter a valid e-mail address in Email Alert.
With Email Alert Frequency, define after how many seconds the e-mail alert should be repeated if any of the real servers remains inaccessible.
In Email Alert Status, specify the server states for which e-mail alerts should be sent. To define more than one state, use a comma-separated list.
With Auto Reload define, if ldirectord should continuously monitor the configuration file for modification. If set to yes, the configuration is automatically reloaded upon changes.
With the Quiescent switch, define whether to remove failed real servers from the Kernel's LVS table or not. If set to Yes, failed servers are not removed. Instead their weight is set to 0, which means that no new connections will be accepted. Already established connections will persist until they time out.
To use an alternative path for logging, specify a path for the log files in Log File. By default, ldirectord writes its log files to /var/log/ldirectord.log.

Figure 17.1: YaST IP load balancing—global parameters #

Procedure 17.2: Configuring virtual services #

You can configure one or more virtual services by defining a couple of parameters for each. The following procedure describes how to configure the most important parameters for a virtual service. For more details about the individual parameters (and the parameters not covered here), click Help or refer to the ldirectord man page.

In the YaST IP Load Balancing module, switch to the Virtual Server Configuration tab.
Add a new virtual server or Edit an existing virtual server. A new dialog shows the available options.
In Virtual Server enter the shared virtual IP address (IPv4 or IPv6) and port under which the load balancers and the real servers are accessible as LVS. Instead of IP address and port number you can also specify a host name and a service. Alternatively, you can also use a firewall mark. A firewall mark is a way of aggregating an arbitrary collection of VIP:port services into one virtual service.
To specify the Real Servers, you need to enter the IP addresses (IPv4, IPv6, or host names) of the servers, the ports (or service names) and the forwarding method. The forwarding method must either be gate, ipip or masq, see Section 17.2.3, “Packet forwarding”.
Click the Add button and enter the required arguments for each real server.
As Check Type, select the type of check that should be performed to test if the real servers are still alive. For example, to send a request and check if the response contains an expected string, select Negotiate.
If you have set the Check Type to Negotiate, you also need to define the type of service to monitor. Select it from the Service drop-down box.
In Request, enter the URI to the object that is requested on each real server during the check intervals.
If you want to check if the response from the real servers contains a certain string (“I'm alive” message), define a regular expression that needs to be matched. Enter the regular expression into Receive. If the response from a real server contains this expression, the real server is considered to be alive.
Depending on the type of Service you have selected in Step 6, you also need to specify further parameters for authentication. Switch to the Auth type tab and enter the details like Login, Password, Database, or Secret. For more information, refer to the YaST help text or to the ldirectord man page.
Switch to the Others tab.
Select the Scheduler to be used for load balancing. For information on the available schedulers, refer to the ipvsadm(8) man page.
Select the Protocol to be used. If the virtual service is specified as an IP address and port, it must be either tcp or udp. If the virtual service is specified as a firewall mark, the protocol must be fwm.
Define further parameters, if needed. Confirm your configuration with OK. YaST writes the configuration to /etc/ha.d/ldirectord.cf.

Figure 17.2: YaST IP load balancing—virtual services #

Example 17.1: Simple ldirectord configuration #

The values shown in Figure 17.1, “YaST IP load balancing—global parameters” and Figure 17.2, “YaST IP load balancing—virtual services”, would lead to the following configuration, defined in /etc/ha.d/ldirectord.cf:

autoreload = yes 1
    checkinterval = 5 2
    checktimeout = 3 3
    quiescent = yes 4
    virtual = 192.168.0.200:80 5
    checktype = negotiate 6
    fallback = 127.0.0.1:80 7
    protocol = tcp 8
    real = 192.168.0.110:80 gate 9
    real = 192.168.0.120:80 gate 9
    receive = "still alive" 10
    request = "test.html" 11
    scheduler = wlc 12
    service = http 13

1	Defines that `ldirectord` should continuously check the configuration file for modification.
2	Interval in which `ldirectord` connects to each of the real servers to check if they are still online.
3	Time in which the real server should have responded after the last check.
4	Defines not to remove failed real servers from the Kernel's LVS table, but to set their weight to `0` instead.
5	Virtual IP address (VIP) of the LVS. The LVS is available at port `80`.
6	Type of check that should be performed to test if the real servers are still alive.
7	Server onto which to redirect a Web service all real servers for this service are down.
8	Protocol to be used.
9	Two real servers defined, both available at port `80`. The packet forwarding method is `gate`, meaning that direct routing is used.
10	Regular expression that needs to be matched in the response string from the real server.
11	URI to the object that is requested on each real server during the check intervals.
12	Selected scheduler to be used for load balancing.
13	Type of service to monitor.

This configuration leads to the following process flow: the ldirectord connects to each real server once every 5 seconds (2) and requests 192.168.0.110:80/test.html or 192.168.0.120:80/test.html as specified in 9 and 11. If it does not receive the expected still alive string (10) from a real server within 3 seconds (3) of the last check, it removes the real server from the available pool. However, because of the quiescent=yes setting (4), the real server is not removed from the LVS table. Instead its weight is set to 0 so that no new connections to this real server are accepted. Already established connections persist until they time out.

17.2.6 Further setup #

Apart from the configuration of ldirectord with YaST, you need to make sure the following conditions are fulfilled to complete the LVS setup:

The real servers are set up correctly to provide the needed services.
The load balancing server (or servers) must be able to route traffic to the real servers using IP forwarding. The network configuration of the real servers depends on which packet forwarding method you have chosen.
To prevent the load balancing server (or servers) from becoming a single point of failure for the whole system, you need to set up one or several backups of the load balancer. In the cluster configuration, configure a primitive resource for ldirectord, so that ldirectord can fail over to other servers in case of hardware failure.
As the backup of the load balancer also needs the ldirectord configuration file to fulfill its task, make sure the /etc/ha.d/ldirectord.cf is available on all servers that you want to use as backup for the load balancer. You can synchronize the configuration file with Csync2 as described in Section 4.7, “Transferring the configuration to all nodes”.

17.3 Configuring load balancing with HAProxy #

The following section gives an overview of the HAProxy and how to set up on High Availability. The load balancer distributes all requests to its back-end servers. It is configured as active/passive, meaning if one server fails, the passive server becomes active. In such a scenario, the user will not notice any interruption.

In this section, we will use the following setup:

A load balancer, with the IP address 192.168.1.99.
A virtual, floating IP address 192.168.1.99.
Our servers (usually for Web content) www.example1.com (IP: 192.168.1.200) and www.example2.com (IP: 192.168.1.201)

To configure HAProxy, use the following procedure:

Install the haproxy package.

Create the file /etc/haproxy/haproxy.cfg with the following contents:

global 1
  maxconn 256
  daemon

defaults 2
  log     global
  mode    http
  option  httplog
  option  dontlognull
  retries 3
  option redispatch
  maxconn 2000
  timeout connect   5000  3
  timeout client    50s   4
  timeout server    50000 5

frontend LB
  bind 192.168.1.99:80 6
  reqadd X-Forwarded-Proto:\ http
  default_backend LB

backend LB
  mode http
  stats enable
  stats hide-version
  stats uri /stats
  stats realm Haproxy\ Statistics
  stats auth haproxy:password	7
  balance roundrobin	8
  option  httpclose
  option forwardfor
  cookie LB insert
  option httpchk GET /robots.txt HTTP/1.0
  server web1-srv 192.168.1.200:80 cookie web1-srv check
  server web2-srv 192.168.1.201:80 cookie web2-srv check

1	Section which contains process-wide and OS-specific options. `maxconn` Maximum per-process number of concurrent connections. `daemon` Recommended mode, HAProxy runs in the background.
2	Section which sets default parameters for all other sections following its declaration. Some important lines: `redispatch` Enables or disables session redistribution in case of connection failure. `log` Enables logging of events and traffic. `mode http` Operates in HTTP mode (recommended mode for HAProxy). In this mode, a request will be analyzed before a connection to any server is performed. Request that are not RFC-compliant will be rejected. `option forwardfor` Adds the HTTP `X-Forwarded-For` header into the request. You need this option if you want to preserve the client's IP address.
3	The maximum time to wait for a connection attempt to a server to succeed.
4	The maximum time of inactivity on the client side.
5	The maximum time of inactivity on the server side.
6	Section which combines front-end and back-end sections in one. `balance leastconn` Defines the load balancing algorithm, see https://cbonte.github.io/haproxy-dconv/configuration-1.5.html#4-balance. `stats enable` , `stats auth` Enables statistics reporting (by `stats enable`). The `auth` option logs statistics with authentication to a specific account.
7	Credentials for HAProxy Statistic report page.
8	Load balancing will work in a round-robin process.

Test your configuration file:

# haproxy -f /etc/haproxy/haproxy.cfg -c

Add the following line to Csync2's configuration file /etc/csync2/csync2.cfg to make sure the HAProxy configuration file is included:
```
include /etc/haproxy/haproxy.cfg
```
Synchronize it:
```
# csync2 -f /etc/haproxy/haproxy.cfg
# csync2 -xv
```
Note
The Csync2 configuration part assumes that the HA nodes were configured using the bootstrap scripts provided by the crm shell. For details, see the Installation and Setup Quick Start.
Make sure HAProxy is disabled on both load balancers (alice and bob) as it is started by Pacemaker:
```
# systemctl disable haproxy
```

Configure a new CIB:

# crm
crm(live)# cib new haproxy-config
crm(haproxy-config)# primitive haproxy systemd:haproxy \
    op start timeout=120 interval=0 \
    op stop timeout=120 interval=0 \
    op monitor timeout=100 interval=5s \
    meta target-role=Started
crm(haproxy-config)# primitive vip IPaddr2 \
    params ip=192.168.1.99 nic=eth0 cidr_netmask=23 broadcast=192.168.1.255 \
    op monitor interval=5s timeout=120 on-fail=restart
crm(haproxy-config)# group g-haproxy vip haproxy

Verify the new CIB and correct any errors:
```
crm(haproxy-config)# verify
```

Commit the new CIB:

crm(haproxy-config)# cib use live
crm(live)# cib commit haproxy-config

17.4 For more information #

https://www.haproxy.org
Project home page at http://www.linuxvirtualserver.org/.
For more information about ldirectord, refer to its comprehensive man page.
LVS Knowledge Base: http://kb.linuxvirtualserver.org/wiki/Main_Page